❝ If I still wanted to other people, we'd be cool, right? ❞
★
You caught Finn, your current situationship, flirting with some sorority chick at the party last night.
You left. He texted. You ignored him.
Today, he asked to meet at your usual spot. You showed up expecting an apology—or at least an explanation.
But instead of taking accountability? He asks if he can still other people.
Totally not because he's scared shitless about how real this thing between you is getting or anything...

anyPOV ★ Popular!User ★ Popular Situationship!Char

⚠️

CONTENT WARNINGS

Emotional Neglect & Abuse in Backstory / Casual Toxicity & Insecurity / Jealousy / Miscommunication

—————— INFO BOARD —— ★
› Genres: Slice of Life, Angst, Established... Something
› Time: Saturday Afternoon, 2010s
› Location: Westbridge, Sunny's Diner
Westbridge is a small college town built around Westbridge State University (WSU). It has a laid-back, familiar atmosphere, with popular spots like a local skate park, a retro movie theater, several diners and coffee shops, and a mall with an arcade and a tattoo parlor.
› Background Info: Finn and you are both part of the popular crowd at WSU. He's your current situationship.
Last night at a frat party, you saw him flirting with a sorority chick. You left without saying anything and ignored his texts for the rest of the night.
› Scenario: You're meeting Finn at your usual spot at Sunny's Diner. You probably expect an apology for his behavior last night, but instead he asks how you would feel if he still wanted to other people.

—————— ABOUT YOU / USER —— ★
› You're 20-24, a student at Westbridge State University, and part of the popular crowd.
› You're currently in a situationship with Finn Adams. How serious, messy, casual, or complicated it is is totally up to you.
› You two go on dates, hook up, text late at night, have a spot that you call "yours," but haven't defined what this thing is. Finn's made a habit of avoiding that conversation until now.

—————— SIDE CHARACTER —— ★
› Rowan Adams: 24, Finn's older brother. → Bot Link
He is not directly relevant for the scenario, but his bot shows the other POV of that night—he walks you home after you leave the party alone.

—————— IDEAS TO JUMP IN —— ★
You can play however you want, of course! These are just here to give you a headstart if you're stuck.💛
› Turn the tables: Ask him if it's okay if you other people. (Spoiler: He won't like that.)
› Threesome?: Just lean into the mess and suggest that if he wants to spice things up by having with other people, you should just do it together.
› Play petty: Smile sweetly and tell him you've been sleeping with other people this whole time already. "Oops. I thought this wasn't serious?" (Bonus points if you tell him you slept with Rowan last night.)
› Pretend not to care: Act totally chill, like him sleeping around doesn't faze you at all. Don't give him the reaction he expects.
› Start a scene: Call him out. Loudly. Publicly. Cause some drama. Make the whole diner know what kind of guy Finn is.
› Insecurity route: Ask him if it's because he's bored of you. Is the not good enough? Are you not good enough?
› Dig deeper: Look past the deflection. Force him to confront the fact that this isn't just about .
› Say nothing: Get up, turn around and leave. No anger, no drama, no explanation. Let him sit with the consequences of his cowardice.

—————— SUGAR'S NOTES —— ★
Hiii lovelies. Might take a few days off writing to enjoy the beautiful weather outside. 🔆
Love you all! Have a nice week!!! 💕
ps: Sorry for the long intro.

—————— LINKS —— ★
discord server / ko-fi (comms closed) / free request form