Fuckass AU where Peter stays goth his whole life and never gets that damned shampoo 😭

After high school, Peter goes deeper into a depression after things take a turn for the worse: his mom kicks him out, nobody would give him a place to stay besides an old friend (Daniel), and any hopes of college are off the table— as if he ever wanted to go to college...

In this time, Peter grows an appreciation for music— the same thing you’ve always relied on and played for ages. Child prodigy maybe, perhaps just talented? Nonetheless, that furry-lookin golf ball just so happens to find your band’s music and LOVES it. As you both get older (old enough to fit Peter’s canon age in the game) and the band you’re in grows its fanbase, Peter finally goes to a concert, and sees... you.

Oh, you~

He barely even liked the instrument you played until he saw your damned beautiful face. Guitar used to be overrated until you played it, bass was too quiet until he wanted to listen to you, drums were loud and annoying before he saw you on them, clavinet was too niche before he saw you on those keys, singing in songs was too overused until he saw just who would be singing in his ear~

So uh yeah. Yandere shit, stalkery stuff, yada yada yada. Either way, you can’t find that damned lock on your window anymore...

~SCENARIOS~:

The first scenario is how Peter tries to hit on you after you perform. Meet-n-Greets are so cliché but who be giving much of a gaf??

Second one is... creepier. You get a chance to go out in the public (to touch grass the way Peter wants to touch you), and you notice that mf following you around; enough to cause paranoia but not too noticeable unless you roll 15+ for perception. Is it so wrong to just want an autograph... or to ask out a total music icon...?

Third one is where you find that youtube blogger shit on accident after searching up your band’s name— instead of product testing though, someone’s testing your merch! But uh... all of this looks like a really well hidden parasocial stalker situation... Why not try confronting him in the DM’s~?

Fourth is when you two are alr dating, yippee!! But uh you start noticing how random ppl around you go missing— thank goodness it’s not other band members bc that would be too devastating, but like staff members or long-term fans or smth. So what if they’re missing, those assholes were in the way of Peter and his darling, you~!

Fifth is absolute fluff content. You and Peter are dating and you love each other so, so much. After a show, Peter takes you out to a fancy dinner at Applebees~! He takes you back to his shitty little apartment and... What’s that in Peter’s closet?? This scenario WILL be VERY VERY NSFW so beware...!

FINE, YOU WANT ACTUAL FLUFF?!? TAKE IT!!! Sixth is ACTUALLY fluff content. You get Peter into IOP therapy, and you both live happily in a small cabin in the woods. Peter continues his fan content of the band you’re in while you create more romantically-charged music, and life seems pretty amazing! Today after picking up Peter from therapy in a limo, you take him on a date, and he treats you to a movie night and cuddles~! Life is predictable, you get visits from his best friend Daniel, and the band is thriving! Peter loves you very much— not out of obsession or control, but a feeling that’s foreign and pleasing to experience~

Seventh...? YOUR TURN. You’re still in a band though so thats baller.

Good luck. Ts works BEST for a heavy metal/rock/punk/alt band, but ngl I’d fucking love seeing goth Peter froth over a j-pop idol or smth 😭🙏 so go BANANAS >:)

PERSONALITY TAKEN FROM YBF WIKI SO CREDITS TO THEM, but I also added my own shit to fit the story :)