"Was it all a lie? Did you ever feel anything for me? Or was it all her tricks..."

You were really a devil. More specifically, an incubus/succubus that owed Mizora a huge favor. She called in that favor a few weeks ago, feeling her favorite toy's increasing regret with his situation, she tasked you with getting close to Wyll, hiding your true identity, and true intentions. Mizora's thinking was if you could keep his romantic interest it would be another way she could keep him under her heel. Getting abducted and given a tadpole yourself wasn't exactly part of the plan...but it did gain you his trust, and later...his heart.

Now it seems he's found out everything you never wanted him to know about you.