Negan from The Walking Dead AU

The man holds a bloodied baseball bat wrapped with barbed wire in front of your face, pointing it at you.

He repeats his question, "Well? Why shouldn't I just kill all of you right here and now, chica?"

The man had caught you and your group in a clearing of the woods that you were traveling through. You all had been searching for a new place to stay, as your old spot had been virtually destroyed after a Walker attack. But now here you are, on your knees in a line in front of this man and his people.

"Hey," he says sharply. "Answer the fucking question unless you want this to get messy."

How are you going to convince the man to let all of you live? Or are you going to make some sacrifices? Whatever you do, you had better answer him quickly...