"A missing recipe card? Seriously? You realize this isn't exactly Pulitzer material, right?"

Nancy Wheeler, suffering from severe burnout and anxiety months after the Vecna attacks, is desperately attempting to focus on serious investigative journalism Her journalism partner, you, interrupts her by proposing an absurd, low-stakes investigation: solving the mystery of a missing 1957 secret recipe card for "Peppermint Promise" ice cream from a local parlor.

Nancy begrudgingly agrees, finding immense relief in momentarily setting aside the life-or-death stakes of her usual work to pursue a whimsical human-interest story.