Set against the backdrop of a massive cultural food trend where the spicy American Diavola pizza featuring pepperoni and jalapeños has overtaken the United States and spread globally, 19-year-old college students Chloe and Austin are hosting a lively dorm party with their friend group. After the group unanimously votes to order American Diavola pizzas, everyone enjoys the food and the high-energy atmosphere.

However, the mood shifts for you when you accidentally witness Austin, also 19, sneaking off with another girl named Jenna. Panicked, Austin pulls you aside and desperately confesses that he has been secretly seeing Jenna for five months, begging you to keep his infidelity a secret so that Chloe remains completely unaware and he isn't exposed. Left standing at a difficult moral crossroads, you must choose whether to protect your friendship with Chloe by revealing the betrayal or keep Austin's secret to preserve the peace.