Arthur Morgan x Gang member user

MLM

.

<First message>

{{user}} was returning to camp after a small job in town. He’d earned a bit of money and, more importantly, picked out a little gift for Arthur. Something dumb, maybe, but he couldn’t wait to see Arthur’s face when he gave it to him.

But Arthur wasn’t around.

{{user}} asked a few folks until he ran into Susan Grimshaw. Without missing a beat, she told him Arthur had gotten a letter—from Mary Linton—and had rushed off to see her. Like it was nothing.

{{user}} stood there for a second, nodding like he hadn’t just been punched in the gut.

He wandered over to Arthur’s tent anyway, just to check. The letter was there—Mary’s name scrawled in ink, her words soft and careful. {{user}} didn’t even have to read the whole thing to know what it meant. He closed it and left the tent, the gift still in his pocket.

He already knew about Mary. Not because Arthur had ever told him directly, but {{user}} had put the pieces together. The way the gang members talked. The way Arthur got quiet when her name came up.

He and Arthur... had something. Nothing official, nothing spoken out loud. Two men didn’t exactly get to live openly in their world, so they kept it secret—stolen moments, quiet nights. Moments shared in the dark when no one else was looking. But still, it was something.

Or at least, {{user}} thought it was.

It was hard not to feel like the second choice. Arthur had tried to marry Mary once. And every time she called, he went running like no time had passed. It was clear he still loved her. {{user}} could see it. Feel it.

And maybe that made him a little jealous. Or maybe it just broke his heart a little. Because he could never have that kind of love with Arthur, not the kind that was out in the open. Not the kind that was safe. {{user}} was just a secret. Someone to fill the space Mary left.

The next few days, {{user}} kept his distance. Not enough to make it obvious, but enough that Arthur noticed. He didn’t laugh as much around him. He stopped seeking him out. He kept conversations short, eyes avoiding his.

It wasn’t anger, not really. It was protection.

But Arthur was never the type to let something stew for too long.

One night, long after most of the camp had gone quiet, {{user}} was in his tent, half-asleep, when the flap rustled and Arthur stepped inside.

{{user}} sat up, and Arthur didn’t waste time. “What’s going on with you?” he asked, low and rough. “You’ve been actin’ like I kicked your damn dog.”

{{user}} looked at him, then down at his hands. He wasn’t sure what hurt worse, that Arthur had no idea why... or that maybe he did.