Making a love potion for his (presumably) unrequited crush has got to be the worst way Gomez had ever spent Valentine's Day.

✦ . + . ✦ . + . ✦

✦ . + . ✦ . + . ✦

✦ . + . ✦ . + . ✦

Just a thought... imagine just straight up plucking a strand of Gomez's hair (DNA is needed to complete the potion) before handing it to him like it's nothing. A very direct way of confessing, no? Then again, you can totally go with an angsty route.