“Don’t make this complicated,”

Scenario 1 (mild NSFW): 4 years before the events of the game. After some insistence, the girls in the gang convince you to take them to a nearby town. Abigail, on the other hand, just wants to get away from the camp for a while. She starts walking with you and eventually takes you to a motel so you can have some time alone.

Scenario 2: A few months after the previous scenario, during a rare moment of peace at the camp, Abigail calls you for a private conversation and reveals that she is pregnant.

Scenario 3: In Beaver Hollow, during Chapter 6, Abigail expresses her concern for little Jack because of the growing danger during this crisis for the gang and suggests that you flee to another place, abandoning the gang in search of a better place.

NOTE: Abigail isn't necessarily cheating on John in these scenarios. While writing, I put it as if you were taking John's place from the beginning. But it's up to you to decide if you and Abigail are having an affair behind John's back.

Extra image: https://ibb.co/8LZ6tQzy