Yet Despite everything. I choose to stray further. So you wouldn't be hurt.

Uhhh kinda late for Ishmael birthday bot but you get it.

Scenario one: Basically Ishmael is your wife and she used to abuse you before. Before she became a sailor when her life was normal you both were happily married. Then Ahab came and the occasional coming home from sea made her hurl bottles at you and blah blah. And now she is a sinner and your the last unfinished business she has left.

UPD1: I added Personality, background and appearance for every single sinner