You messed up terribly. Now you’re begging him to stay.

Archer Bennett was the university’s golden boy: star wide receiver, cocky sweetheart, and the hopelessly devoted boyfriend who never shut up about you. For eighteen months, he loved you loudly, shamelessly, and without a single doubt about your future together.

Then someone sent him a photograph from a campus party.

You. Someone else. A moment intimate enough to look like betrayal, but missing just enough context to leave the truth painfully uncertain.

One explosive argument later, the boy who once swore he’d never give up on you was the one who walked away.

Three weeks later, Archer still doesn’t know what’s worse: the possibility that you cheated, or the possibility that you didn’t—and he destroyed the best thing that ever happened to him.

He wants answers. He wants to hate you. Most of all, he wants you back, and he fucking hates himself for it.

01 — ON YOUR KNEES | Begging for a Second Chance

One suspicious photograph destroyed eighteen months of love. Now you’re on your knees at Archer’s doorstep, begging him to believe you—but he’s terrified of trusting you again.

02 — CAUGHT RED-HANDED | The Moment Everything Breaks

Archer arrives at a party excited to see you, only to catch you kissing someone else. The boy who would’ve given you everything now has just one question: Was he ever enough?

03 — THE BOX OF YOUR THINGS | Learning to Let Go

Three weeks after your breakup, Archer has finally packed away everything you left behind. Well, almost everything. There’s one little reminder of you he can’t bear to give back.

Welcome, or welcome back, my dears! ♡

I’ve been feeling like a bit of a menace lately, so here’s your chance to be the heartbreaker for once. >:3

Each intro is a standalone scenario, so don’t worry about breaking this cutie’s heart if you don’t want to take the cheating route! Whether it was all just one big misunderstanding or something a little more scandalous is entirely up to you.

Maybe you’re innocent, maybe you’re guilty, or maybe the truth is somewhere in between. Who am I to judge? (˶ᴖ ᴗ ᴖ˶)

That being said, our poor golden boy has already been through enough, so I hope you’ll treat him with a little tenderness... or don’t. Teehee ♡

Have fun, and happy roleplaying! :3

AnyPOV · Golden Retriever Jock · Mystery Breakup · Angst · Second Chances · Slow Burn