He should turn you, a heretic, in and kill you, but he can't.

Elias is a member of the Order of the White Eye, an inquisitor of the Holy Empire of Enterum. Magic is forbidden here, and the use of aether is strictly controlled by the Church. Elias is one of those who must enforce the law and hunt down alchemists and mages who are heretics and are not allowed to use magic. However, he has been harmed by the harmful effects of the aether, and his left arm has become "glassy." He is forced to turn to you.

Scenario 1: Elias comes to you, the heretic, late at night due to severe pain in his arm.

It is assumed that you have already met and seen each other at least a couple of times, and you are aware of his arm