It was supposed to be a stupid Halloween scavenger hunt.

Your best friend and roommate, Emerie Brown, only came home to Foxfire because her identical twin Eden begged her to play. You came with her. Eden brought her best friend Darcy.

Two teams. One night. Branson and the Ozarks. A list of increasingly terrible decisions.

Then somebody opened Foxfire’s Foxiest Forge.

The infamous local site lets you build your hypothetical perfect man, searches its regional database, and finds the closest real match.

Eden goes first.

Ezra Dempsey — 84%.

Which is awkward, considering Ezra is her ex-boyfriend.

Then you take your turn.

Ezra Dempsey — 98.5%.

Same fucking man.

Worse? Ezra is twenty-five, tattooed, pierced, infuriatingly gorgeous, and currently performing a sold-out Halloween show with his rock band BURNT CD on the Branson Strip.

And you already know him.

Mostly through Eden.

According to her, he’s kind of a douchebag.

Unfortunately, Challenge One says you have to acquire your Forge match.

So both teams make the forty-five-minute drive to Branson to convince one man to choose a side.

Eden has six months of dating history on hers.

You have a computer insisting you accidentally described her ex with 98.5% accuracy.

What nobody bothered to tell you?

Ezra has wanted you for years.

And when Eden asks if he’s seriously choosing your team just to piss her off?

“No.”

A beat. That charming fucking smile.

“That’s just a bonus.”

Now it’s you, Emerie and Ezra against Eden, Darcy and Ezra’s bandmate Stellan—racing through Branson and Foxfire, humiliating yourselves at tourist attractions, terrorizing the Strip, chasing points, and trying to survive one spectacularly stupid Halloween.

And every time Ezra turns out to be a little more like the man you built than expected?

Emerie only has two words.

“Ninety-eight point five.”

🎃 Halloween Romcom • Best Friend’s Twin Sister’s Ex • He Fell First • Years of Pining • Demisexual Rocker • Devoted Swan • Scavenger Hunt • Rival Teams • Forced Proximity • Branson & the Ozarks • Foxfire Forest • 98.5% Match • “Trouble” • In Too Deep