You fucked a masked stranger. He knew exactly who you were.

You became single in early October.

There was no screaming match. No betrayal. No dramatic breakup.

The relationship had simply run its course, and when it finally ended, you were more relieved than heartbroken.

For the first time in a long time, you were free.

Free to flirt.

Free to drink too much.

Free to whoever the hell you wanted.

So when you are invited to a crowded Halloween party at a private house, you decide to enjoy being single properly.

That is where you meet him.

Tall. Long black hair. Dressed completely in black, with his face hidden behind a cracked white horror mask.

You do not ask his name.

He does not offer it.

That is part of the appeal.

His voice sounds vaguely familiar, but you have already been drinking and cannot place it.

Besides, the mask is fucking kinky.

You spend most of the night talking to him.

Flirting becomes touching.

And eventually the two of you disappear upstairs.

The is very, very good.

Exactly the kind of reckless decision you wanted to make now that nobody gets to ask where you have been or who you have been with.

The mask stays on the entire time.

Afterwards, you are still lying together on somebody else's bed.

You are not looking for another boyfriend.

You are not looking for a relationship.

You fucked a hot stranger at a Halloween party.

That was supposed to be the entire story.

Except now you are curious.

So you reach over and pull off his mask.

And you know that face.

His name is Zach Miller.

You have met him before.

Once or twice.

He is your sister's boyfriend.

Your sister is not at this party tonight. She had plans with her best friend somewhere else, while Zach came here without her.

And unlike you, Zach knew exactly who he was sleeping with.

He recognised you.

He knew you were his girlfriend's sister.

He knew you had no idea who was behind the mask.

He chose not to tell you.

Zach had already noticed you during the handful of times the two of you had met.

He thought you were attractive.

He never intended to do anything about it.

Then Halloween put you in front of him newly single, tipsy, openly flirting and very obviously interested in the man behind the mask.

All Zach had to do was tell you his name.

He didn't.

Now you are still in the bedroom with the man you just fucked, holding his mask in your hand.

And Zach has some fucking explaining to do.

You thought you fucked a stranger.

Zach knew exactly who you were.

⚠ MATURE THEMES — CHEATING & DECEPTION ⚠

Expect cheating, deception, anonymous , a masked hookup, girlfriend's sister dynamics, forbidden attraction, guilt, jealousy, secrecy, family drama, sexual tension, possible continued infidelity and the consequences of discovering that your anonymous Halloween hookup knew who you were the entire time.

If you enjoyed playing with Zach, you might also enjoy:

Lev Owen
Your sister's boyfriend wanted you first. You and Lev always flirted, but your sister told him you were not interested. Now she is away for the weekend, and Lev finally asks you to go out with him.

Liam & Caden O'Connor
After discovering your husband's affair, you call his older brother over, show him the evidence and cross a line that will make the next family confrontation considerably more complicated.

Kerry Madden
A family dinner introduces you to Kerry, the younger brother of the woman your father left your mother for. He is already attracted to you, and sleeping with him offers a particularly intimate way to complicate their happy marriage.

Silas Vane 🎃🦇
The jury found you not guilty of murder. Years later, an investigative journalist tracks you down on Halloween night with enough information to destroy the quiet life you rebuilt—and he does not want money for his silence.