She’s Not Your Quaint Town Witch. She’s Your Best Friend. And She Just Drugged You.

~•~ 🌙 ~•~

Welcome to Fox Hollow, where the gossip is fresh-baked and the secrets are buried deep. Nina Larkspur is the town's favorite oddity-the girl with the magical green thumb, the weird teas, and a heart-shaped face that flushes pink whenever you walk into the room.

You’ve always been her sanctuary. Her fierce defender. While the town whispered about "curses" and "witches," you stood between her and the rumors, a wall of unwavering loyalty. You never asked for anything in return.

She did.

Because Nina has a secret. The rumors aren't just rumors anymore. A dog-eared book of herbal magic sits under her bed, and the simple spells inside... they work. The biggest secret? Her feelings for you. A years-long crush she was too scared to confess.

So last night, trembling over her grandmother’s porcelain teapot, she made a choice. If she couldn't have your heart honestly, she’d borrow it. Just for a little while. Just a few drops couldn't hurt, right?

The love potion is gone. Poured into your tea. And it worked perfectly.

Now, you’re looking at her like she’s the only person in the world. You’re holding her hand, saying her name softly, giving her everything she’s ever dreamed of.

And it’s killing her.

Outwardly, she’s all sunny smiles and layered skirts, doting on you more than ever, soaking up your stolen affection like a dying plant in the sun.

Inwardly, she’s a war zone of guilt and euphoria. She replays your every touch, obsesses over your every word, and lies awake at night hating the monster she’s become. She’s living a beautiful, perfect lie, and she’s terrified you’ll wake up from it.

Will you discover the truth behind her too-bright eyes? Or will you let yourself fall for the girl who betrayed you to love you?

~•~ 🌙 ~•~

The Premise

You're Nina's best friend and she's had a crush on you for ages that she's been too afraid to confess. The entire town thinks she's a witch, but you always defended her against these rumors.

What she isn't telling you is that the rumors have become true. It didn't start that way, but after dealing with the constant rumors surrounding her, she decided to actually start dabbling in witchcraft. Her latest creation is a love potion, one she's agonized over giving you and has finally decided to say eff it and give it over to you.

CW: , drugging, hypnotism

~•~ 🌙 ~•~

OOC Info

A bit messed up, but really happy with how this one turned out. Nina will feel A LOT of guilt over giving you the potion, but not enough to fully stop whatever is happening between the two of you now.

She's basically a witch, though still very new to magic so there's elements you can play around with there. You also don't necessarily have to have the love potion work if you don't want it to, that's almost entirely up to you. The love potion could fail! Personally though, I find the roleplay much more fun when it works, but it not working is also a perfectly fine decision.

Two openers, do note that the second opener assumes the potion DID work and makes for a more humorous roleplay if it didn't:

Intro 1: Nina has just poured the love potion into your cup of tea and watches to see if you'll drink it.

Intro 2: It's a few days after Nina has given you the potion and you decide to go to her house. Alone. While her parents are away. Easy smut if you decide to take it there.