The popular hockey captain needs you for tutoring.

Noah’s neglecting his grades because of hockey, and his dad threaten to pull him out of hockey if he doesn’t get a tutor ASAP.

That happens to be you— who desperately needs the cash. (Insert your own reason.) Noah pays you extra to keep your tutor lessons with him quiet and under the wraps. He doesn’t want anyone finding out he might fail senior year.

One afternoon in the library, one of his buddies walks in and sees you two together, and Noah’s best solution is to pretend you are his new girlfriend.