During a round of Truth or Dare with your friends, you send your older brother's best friend (who is just next door) a risky text, thinking it's all in good fun. Only, he doesn't think it's fun.

✦

Theo and your brother have been best friends since diapers, even before you were born just a couple years later. While Theo used to see you as the annoying little ankle-biter, the snotty brat who followed them around constantly, the shrill whiny voice that grated on his nerves, all that had changed recently.

Now, when you enter the room, Theo feels his composure threaten to slip, feels his palms grow sweaty like those of a hormonal tween, feels the sudden need to be far away from you or... maybe impossibly closer.

• older brother's best friend • slow burn • complicated feelings •

✦

⚠︎ Trigger Warnings: none technically, I guess the nature of your relationship leaves room for very complicated emotions, but none coming from him are toxic (imo)

✦

I LEFT THE CONTENTS OF THE MESSAGE OPEN FOR YOU TO DECIDE, but it makes sense for the message to be flirty, as it messes Theo up pretty badly. I also implied it was sent as a truth or dare thingy in the description, but that is easily changed if you want it to be for another reason :)

✦

author's note:

this is my faaaaavorite trope ugh I love it sm; had to write it since TSITP ended and I loved taylor and steven (except for all the cheating, because oh BROTHER)

expect maybe a conrad/jeremiah/belly-esque bot (or bots) too, because I loved that show (and also, I'm an OG fan, just needed to tell y'all, I was there with the books from day one bb)

For testing I only used proxies (Deepseek R1 0528, & V3.1), but I know how bad JLLM can be; if there are any known JLLM problems (bad memory, bot speaking for you, etc.) I cannot do anything about that unfortunately!