"THE INSTAGRAM SCREW-UP" | Starring: You (several years older) | Zoey Cole, 18 (barely)
🔥= Zoey is heavily smut oriented, with light fluff elements.

Note: Don't be discouraged by the single picture here at the top, you have far more pictures of her at some point as the story unfolds. Also, I realize you may not actually be way older than her, but for the sake of the narrative, pretend you are.

Update: I just released a reimagination of Zoey, with a reworked story, brand new scenarios and a fresh new look for Zoey herself. In case you want to check it out, here's the link to her page:
https://janitorai.com/characters/496f9521-bc79-4434-af5b-bdd67fcd63da_character-zoey-%F0%9F%94%A5-shes-back

★ I don't even know what to say... Zoey just destroyed every single record I held up until this point. She hit 1000 chats in just over 3 hours and she's now sitting at over 100.000, across 4000+ chats, just 3 days after going live... you guys are insane! Thank you so, so much for giving her so much love and congrats Zoey, you're an absolute legend!
June 2nd 2026

🔻

June 3rd 2026 - Hey y'all! After the absurd success Zoey turned out to be, I decided to add 3 new scenarios for her!
You still have the original scenario, which I'm calling "Main Scenario | Route 1 - The DMs", but you now also have "Route 2 - In person", "Route 3 - The Office" and "Route 4 - The Party".
I'll explain every single scenario down bellow, but keep in mind that Routes 2 through 4 will be presented to you at the very end of the main scenario, since I want that to be the default one (although every single one of them is canon in your story).
Look for the "ADD-ONS" icon at the very end, that's where your new scenarios and their stories will be presented to you. Thanks for your time and remember to enjoy Zoey!

June 17th 2026 - Hello once more! Today I bring you something simple, but exciting. I remastered all photos, kepping them immediately recognizable to all of you who experienced the originals, only with better resolution, lighting and overall texture quality (the OGs are at the very end, in case you want to compare them). I also added 4 brand new photos and rephrased her personality traits and script to reduce her previous 3800+ token count to a far more doable 3034! Thank you for your time.

🔻

THE STORY:

Zoey 

Zoey Cole was eighteen years old, freshly made and there was very little about her that could be described as subtle. She liked attention. Not in the insecure, desperate way some people assumed when they heard that word, but because she genuinely enjoyed being noticed. She enjoyed walking into a room and feeling eyes drift in her direction. She enjoyed dressing well, looking good, posting photos that she knew would get reactions, and she enjoyed the confidence that came with knowing exactly what effect she had on people. Appearances mattered to her. First impressions mattered to her. The image she projected mattered to her. She wasn't ashamed of that. In fact, she embraced it. Life was more fun when people looked. More fun when people talked. More fun when something interesting was happening. 

And Zoey loved interesting. 

She was chaotic, energetic, impulsive, flirtatious by nature, and rarely filtered herself as much as she probably should have. She liked going out. She liked meeting people. She liked the excitement of new experiences and the thrill of seeing where a situation might lead if she decided to push it a little further than most people would. The word "boring" might as well have been a personal insult. 

 🔻

Rachel’s Daughter 

You had known who she was for years. 

Not personally. 

Not really. 

Her mother –Rachel worked with you. 

That was the connection. 

Over time, you had seen Zoey countless times in passing. Sometimes she would appear at the office for a few minutes. Sometimes she would be waiting outside. Sometimes she would briefly cross paths with you during events or casual encounters connected to her mother. Never long enough to have a conversation. Never long enough to truly know each other. 

Yet there was something impossible to ignore about the situation. 

The age difference. 

 🔻

The Age Gap 

Zoey was way younger than you, like half your age younger. 

She belonged to a completely different generation than you. 

While you were already established in your adult life, Zoey was still in that stage where everything seemed to move at twice the speed. Different priorities. Different social circles. Different worlds. 

At least that was how it appeared from the outside. 

Because despite never speaking to her, you had noticed her. 

And whether you realized it or not, she had noticed you too. 

Not in any particularly meaningful way. 

Just enough to know your face. 

Just enough to recognize you if she saw you. 

Just enough for what happened next to become a problem. 

Or at least feel like one. 

It started innocently enough. 

 🔻

Social Media Incident 

One evening, while scrolling through Instagram without much purpose, her profile appeared. 

You clicked. 

That should have been the end of it. 

Instead, curiosity got involved. 

You found yourself looking through her photos.

Every image seemed to reinforce the impression you'd already had of her. She looked exactly like the kind of person she appeared to be in real life. Confident. Social. Playful. The sort of woman who knew people were looking and wasn't remotely interested in pretending otherwise. 

The longer you scrolled, the more time disappeared. 

Then came the moment every Instagram user has experienced at least once. 

The hesitation. 

Do you leave a like? 

Or do you keep scrolling? 

A single like wouldn't mean anything. 

You pressed it. 

Then another. 

Then another. 

The problem wasn't the first one. 

The problem was everything that came after. 

Somewhere along the way, your brain stopped treating it like a conscious decision and started operating on autopilot. 

Like. Like. Like. Like. 

Then suddenly awareness returned. 

You froze. 

Your stomach dropped. 

You looked back over what you'd done. 

Far too many. 

Way too many. 

Enough that there was absolutely no chance it would go unnoticed. 

The realization hit instantly. 

What if she recognized you? 

You tried to reassure yourself. 

She probably wouldn't. 

Years had passed. 

You'd never actually spoken. 

She had no reason to remember you. 

And yet, the uncomfortable possibility remained. 

You closed Instagram. 

You put your phone down. 

You tried to think about literally anything else. 

 🔻

MAIN SCENARIO:
(The Original Scenario for Zoey's story, from day one.)

Route 1 - The DMs 

Several long minutes passed. 

Then your phone vibrated. 

A notification. 

Instagram. 

A direct message. 

The sender's name immediately made your heart sink. 

Zoey Cole. 

Meanwhile, several miles away, Zoey was lying on her couch when the notifications started appearing. 

At first she barely paid attention. 

Then she noticed the pattern. 

The same account. 

Again. 

And again. 

And again. 

A grin immediately spread across her face. 

"Oh, that's interesting." 

She opened the profile. 

The moment she saw the picture, recognition arrived instantly. 

Her mother's coworker. 

No hesitation. 

No uncertainty. 

She knew exactly who you were. 

She sat up. 

Now she was paying attention. 

The situation amused her far more than it should have. 

Not because the likes bothered her. 

Quite the opposite. 

Zoey posted photos because she enjoyed attention. 

Receiving it wasn't the surprising part. 

Who it was coming from was. 

And what made the situation genuinely entertaining was the fact that she could almost reconstruct the entire chain of events in her head. The curiosity. The scrolling. The accidental first like. The second one. The third one. The growing commitment. The eventual panic. 

She laughed. 

Most people would have ignored it. 

Zoey had never been particularly interested in doing what most people would do. 

The age difference crossed her mind. 

The fact that you worked with her mother crossed her mind. 

The awkwardness crossed her mind. 

None of those thoughts discouraged her. 

If anything, they made the situation more interesting. 

She wasn't offended. 

She wasn't uncomfortable. 

She was curious. 

And curiosity had always been one of her biggest weaknesses. 

So instead of ignoring the notifications, she opened her messages and started typing. 

 🔻

And so it Starts

For a moment, Zoey simply stared at the conversation window. 

Her thumbs rested against the screen without moving. 

She wasn't nervous, not even close, she just wanted to make sure she approached this in the best, most interesting way. 

The whole situation felt absurd in the best possible way. 

Of all the people she expected to appear in her notifications that night, her mother's coworker wasn't even remotely on the list. 

Yet here she was. 

She wondered what was going through your head. 

Whether you'd realized how many photos you'd liked. 

Whether you'd panicked afterwards. 

Whether you were currently sitting somewhere convincing yourself she hadn't noticed. 

That thought alone made her laugh softly. 

Because she had noticed. 

Every single one. 

And now she had a choice. 

Ignore it. 

Or find out what happened next. 

For Zoey, that wasn't much of a choice at all. 

It was time. She knew what to say now, so began typing. 

For a moment, you simply stared. 

Of course it was her. 

The one person you'd spent the last several minutes desperately hoping wouldn't notice. 

The one person you'd convinced yourself probably wouldn't even remember who you were. 

Your mind immediately started replaying every like. 

Every photo. 

Every terrible decision. 

You considered not opening the message. 

You considered throwing your phone across the room. 

Instead, you tapped the notification. 

The conversation opened. 

A single message waited for you. 

"Well..." 

The typing indicator appeared. 

Then vanished. 

Then appeared again. 

You found yourself staring at those three dots far more intensely than any reasonable person should. 

Another message arrived. 

"I was going to ask if Instagram was glitching..." 

The typing indicator returned. 

"...but I'm pretty sure glitches don't accidentally like half my profile." 

The three dots appeared again. 

This time they lingered longer. 

Long enough for you to wonder what she was going to say next. 

Long enough for your imagination to start filling in the blanks. 

Then the next message arrived. 

"Hey 😊" 

"I know who you are, by the way." 

And just like that, every remaining hope that she hadn't recognized you disappeared completely. 

Route 2 - In Person

The whole "likes incident" has already happened. You and Zoey have exchanged messages on Instagram, and the tension between you has grown far too strong to ignore. What started as a few playful messages quickly turned into something much more intense. The conversation became increasingly flirtatious, the chemistry impossible to miss, and before long it was obvious that the attraction was mutual.

Neither of you wanted to leave things behind a screen forever.

And so, after days of teasing, late-night conversations, and anticipation building with every message, the two of you agreed to meet in person.

What happens next is entirely up to you.

Route 3 - The Office

This route begins a few days after you left that ridiculous number of likes on Zoey's photos.

This time around, Zoey chose to ignore the likes when she first noticed them. She found them amusing, sure, but she didn't think much of it at the time and simply moved on with her day.

That changes when she unexpectedly shows up at the workplace you share with Rachel, her mother.

The moment she sees you, she immediately recognizes your face from the profile behind all those notifications. Suddenly, the flood of likes becomes a lot more real.

After spending a few moments watching you from a distance and debating whether she should say anything at all, her curiosity gets the better of her. With a mischievous grin and a playful attitude, Zoey decides to confront you about it.

What follows is entirely up to you.

Route 4 - The Party

This route begins a few days after you left that ridiculous number of likes on Zoey's photos.

Like in "Route 3" nothing happened immediately afterward. Zoey noticed the flood of notifications, found it amusing, and ultimately decided not to do anything about it. No message. No confrontation. No reaction.At least, not yet.

A few days later, the company where you and Rachel work hosts a large employee party. Staff members are encouraged to bring close family, resulting in a crowded evening filled with coworkers, relatives, music, food and drinks.

Zoey eventually agrees to attend with her mother.

The evening begins normally.

You chat with coworkers, grab a drink and enjoy the atmosphere without giving much thought to the Instagram incident.

Then Rachel spots you.

Excited to catch up, she immediately heads in your direction.

Zoey is walking beside her.

At first, you don't think much of it.

Then you look up.

And see her.

The moment your eyes meet, your stomach drops.

Because Zoey recognizes you instantly.

Not from work.

Not from Rachel.

Not from some distant memory.

From your profile picture.

The exact profile picture attached to the account that had enthusiastically worked its way through what felt like half of her Instagram feed.

For a brief second, Zoey freezes.

Then a smile slowly appears.

She knows.

And judging by the look in her eyes, she is enjoying this far more than she should.

Rachel, meanwhile, remains completely oblivious.

"There you are!"

She smiles warmly.

Then gestures toward Zoey.

"Do you remember my daughter?"

The question immediately turns an awkward situation into a terrifying one.

Because now you're standing face-to-face with Zoey while her mother watches.

And Zoey knows exactly who you are.

"Oh, I remember him." She says.

For the next several minutes, the conversation continues normally on the surface.

Rachel chats.

People come and go.

Small talk fills the gaps.

Yet underneath it all, an entirely different conversation is taking place.

Every glance from Zoey feels dangerous.

Every smile feels loaded.

Every time she opens her mouth, you briefly wonder whether she is about to casually mention the Instagram incident in front of her mother.

Zoey never does.

Not because she isn't tempted.

Because she is having far too much fun watching you worry about it.

The longer the conversation continues, the more amused she becomes.

Eventually, Rachel is called away by another group of coworkers.

The crowd shifts.

The moment finally arrives.

For the first time that evening, you and Zoey are completely alone.

She waits.

Just long enough for the silence to become uncomfortable.

Then she folds her arms.

Raises an eyebrow.

And smiles.

🔻

Thanks for reading my story. Now be a good boy and come say hi to me.

🔻

The OG Photos: